UK FACT CHECK POLITICS
UK FACT CHECK POLITICS
Voting intention Labour Lab 31% Reform Ref 25% Con Con 23% Green Grn 8% Lib Dem LD 7% Poll tracker
Menu
Account

Burnham backs Milburn youth review but leaves benefit changes to White Paper

✓ Fact-checked 92/100 · High Trust
Burnham backs Milburn youth review but leaves benefit changes to White Paper
Greater Manchester Mayor Andy Burnham speaks at a lectern fitted with microphones during a press conference, wearing a dark suit jacket over a black T-shirt with a Manchester worker bee lapel pin. He stands in front of a dark green panelled backdrop.

The government has backed the core principles of Alan Milburn's review of young people and work and has committed to three immediate measures in response, according to a government press release issued on Tuesday. They are locally led youth services from next year, a guaranteed route into education, training or work, and a Youth Opportunities Unit reporting directly to the Prime Minister.

The release leaves open the report's most contested recommendations, which concern benefits for under-25s. It makes no reference to the new youth allowance that Milburn proposes in place of Personal Independence Payment (PIP) and the health element of Universal Credit, or to withdrawing that allowance from young people who do not engage with support. It says the wider recommendations will be considered alongside the Timms Review of PIP, with a White Paper in the new year.

The Prime Minister, Andy Burnham, said in the release: "We will carefully consider all the recommendations and come back with the Government's full response in the coming weeks, but our direction is already clear: a fundamental overhaul of how we support young people."

He added: "Rather than making crude cuts which do not and have never worked we will invest in success instead of continuing to pay for failure through the benefits system."

Milburn, a former Labour Health Secretary, published his final report, From a Welfare State to a Working State: a new settlement for the next generation, on Tuesday. Pat McFadden, the Work and Pensions Secretary, commissioned the review in November 2025 after a rise in the number of 16 to 24-year-olds not in education, employment or training, known as NEET.

Under the plans set out in the release, the new local services will bring employment, health, skills and wider youth support together in one place, with mayors and local leaders shaping them. For 18 to 24-year-olds who are out of education or work, or at serious risk of becoming so, they will become the main route into support.

The release describes an Opportunity and Support Guarantee, under which every young person would have a real opportunity to gain a college place, training, an apprenticeship, high-quality work experience or a job, with health, employment and practical support to take it up. It says support will come first, followed by an expectation that young people participate, and that a safety net will remain for those who cannot work.

The Youth Opportunities Unit is intended to join up education, employment, health and local government. McFadden has also told MPs that the unit will report directly to the Prime Minister, according to a report published by Brit Brief.

The release gives no funding figures for any of the three measures. It says further detail on local delivery, funding and implementation, "including through legislation", will be set out in due course.

It does not say whether the guarantee will be statutory. Milburn told the BBC before publication that he wanted a legal duty on government. "It should be a guarantee for a young person," he said.

McFadden said in the release: "We need a new settlement for the next generation and that is why we will fundamentally redesign the system around early intervention and clear expectations, giving young people a future to match their talents."

The benefit proposals have already divided Labour. ITV has reported the proposed youth allowance at about £80 a week, while STV has reported that it would be set at the standard Universal Credit rate for under-25s, with a higher rate for those living independently.

"There will be people who will lose, but there'll be many people who will gain," Milburn said at the report's launch, according to STV. He told Sky News that some young people would be worse off, at least initially, and that Labour MPs "have to vote for it", the Press Association reported.

Labour MPs on the party's left have urged ministers not to "make disabled people poorer", according to a report carried by AOL before publication.

ITV has reported that Milburn's plan would cost nearly £6bn a year, and that the cost would exceed benefit savings and extra tax revenue until at least 2036. The report itself says reform "may cost more before it saves money", according to FE News.

The release gives differing accounts of when the full response will come. Its main text says next steps on welfare reform will be set out in the coming weeks, ahead of a White Paper next year. Burnham refers to a full response in the coming weeks, while the notes accompanying the release say the full response to both the Milburn and Timms reports will come in the White Paper.

The release puts the number of young people who are NEET at close to a million. The Office for National Statistics estimated the figure at 981,000 for April to June 2026, down from 1.01 million in January to March, which was the highest level in more than 12 years. Its next estimate is due on 26 November.

You read this free. Help keep it free for everyone. No paywall, no owner with an agenda. Reader support pays for the research.

Get email updates

Our latest reporting and fact checks in your inbox. Free, and one click to leave.

Join the Discussion

Have something to say? Join the conversation!

Sign in to share your thoughts and engage with other readers.

Sign In Create Account

No comments yet

Be the first to share your thoughts on this article!