Biden was waving to people out of frame, not an empty field

[Skip to content]( [Menu]( []( [The Poynter Institute]( [Donate]( []( * [Campaigns]( * [2026 Midterms]( * [State Editions]( * [California]( * [Florida]( * [Iowa]( * [Michigan]( * [New Hampshire]( * [New York]( * [North Carolina]( * [Pennsylvania]( * [Texas]( * [West Virginia]( * [Wisconsin]( * [Issues]( * [All Issues]( * [Online Hoaxes]( * [Coronavirus]( * [Health Care]( * [Immigration]( * [Extremism]( * [Taxes]( * [Marijuana]( * [Environment]( * [Crime]( * [Guns]( * [Foreign Policy]( * [LGBTQ+]( * [Well Informed]( * [People]( * [Donald Trump]( * [JD Vance]( * [Mitch McConnell]( * [Mike Johnson]( * [Joe Biden]( * [Media]( * [PunditFact]( * [Tucker Carlson]( * [Sean Hannity]( * [Rachel Maddow]( * [Bloggers]( * [PolitiFact Videos]( * [Truth-o-Meter]( * [True]( * [Mostly True]( * [Half True]( * [Mostly False]( * [False]( * [Pants on Fire]( * [About]( * [Our Process]( * [Our Staff]( * [En Español]( * [Who pays for PolitiFact?]( * [Advertise with Us]( * [Corrections and Updates]( * [Newsletters]( * [Promises]( * [MAGA-Meter]( * [Biden Promise Tracker]( * [Trump-O-Meter]( * [Obameter]( * [Latest Promises]( [Donate]( **Follow us** []( **The Facts Newsletter** Sign Up * [English]( * [Español]( ### Stand up for the facts! Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy. We need your help. [More Info]( #### I would like to contribute $ Join Now! []( [Facebook posts]( stated on September 16, 2020 in a Facebook post: “This Is Real: Biden Waves To An Empty Field.” [Facebook Fact-checks]( posts]( This claim rates False. []( By[Noah Y. Kim]( September 21, 2020 # No, Biden didn’t wave to an empty field in Florida #### If your time is short • Biden was waving to firefighters and ground personnel out of frame.​ • Two videos more clearly show Biden waving toward a firetruck at the other end of the field. [See the sources for this fact-check]( On Sept. 15, Joe Biden arrived in Tampa, Fla., for a campaign event, and as he descended the stairs of the airplane, he waved. One video capturing the moment spread quickly on social media as Facebook users shared it with [derisive]( suggesting Biden was waving to an empty field. However, the video truly took off when Fox News host Sean Hannity [posted]( it to his account with the title, “This Is Real: Biden Waves To An Empty Field.” Yes, the video is real — but the field wasn’t empty. This Facebook post was flagged as part of Facebook’s efforts to combat false news and misinformation on its News Feed. (Read more about our [partnership with Facebook]( According to an [Associated Press]( reporter who was there with Biden as he left the plane, the Democratic nominee was waving to a group of firefighters and personnel who were out of the frame due to the camera angle. Another [video]( of Biden descending the stairs clearly shows him waving in the direction of a firetruck at the other end of the field. And in yet [another video]( shared by Bloomberg News reporter Tyler Pager, four people are seen standing near the fire truck facing him. We rate this post False. _This fact check is available at IFCN’s 2020 US Elections FactChat #Chatbot on WhatsApp. Click [here]( for more._ ##### **Our Sources** AP, "[Video does not show Biden waving to an empty field,]( Sep. 16, 2020 Facebook [post]( Sep. 15, 2020 Facebook [post]( Sep. 15, 2020 Facebook [post]( Sep. 16, 2020 [Tweet]( Sep. 15, 2020 [Tweet]( Sep. 15, 2020 #### Read About Our Process [The Principles of the Truth-O-Meter]( ## Browse the Truth-O-Meter ##### More by Noah Y. Kim []( []( [Facebook posts]( stated on October 14, 2020 in Facebook posts: [A leaked email from a Liberal Party politician shows the Canadian government’s plan to “reset” the economy and seize private property.]( By[Noah Y. Kim]( April 29, 2021 []( [Instagram posts]( stated on March 25, 2021 in an Instagram post: [Says H.R. 1 gives immigrants illegally in the country “the right to vote.”]( By[Noah Y. Kim]( March 31, 2021 []( [Facebook posts]( stated on March 26, 2021 in Facebook posts: [Nostradamus predicted that a “feeble man” would rule the “Western World” after a time of “plague.”]( By[Noah Y. Kim]( March 30, 2021 []( [Facebook posts]( stated on October 17, 2021 in a Rumble video: [There is an “epidemic of plane crashes linked to vaccine-related strokes in pilots.”]( By[Noah Y. Kim]( October 19, 2021 []( [Instagram posts]( stated on August 14, 2021 in Instagram posts: [Department of Homeland Security “deemed as terrorism” behavior that includes “resisting COVID regulations” and “thinking the election was rigged.”…“In other words, if you are a Trump supporter, you are a terrorist.”]( By[Noah Y. Kim]( October 12, 2021 []( [Facebook posts]( stated on October 3, 2021 in Facebook posts: [“This ‘infrastructure bill’ on page 2,385 presents a federal property tax of 3 percent on all homes and land – both residential and commercial.”]( By[Noah Y. Kim]( October 4, 2021 []( [Bloggers]( stated on September 27, 2021 in Articles: [Norway decided “that (the coronavirus) should be treated like other respiratory diseases, such as the flu or cold, because… it is no more dangerous than those mentioned.”]( By[Noah Y. Kim]( September 30, 2021 []( [Facebook posts]( stated on September 26, 2021 in Facebook posts: [The Biden-backed infrastructure bill contains a provision establishing a per-mile driving tax.]( By[Noah Y. Kim]( September 29, 2021 []( [Facebook posts]( stated on September 1, 2021 in Facebook posts: [News cameras “shut off” just as Biden was asked if he gave the Taliban a “hit list” of evacuating American and Afghan officials.]( By[Noah Y. Kim]( September 28, 2021 []( [Facebook posts]( stated on September 26, 2021 in Facebook posts: [“The Arizona forensic audit found over 17,000 duplicates of votes.”]( By[Noah Y. Kim]( September 27, 2021 []( [TikTok posts]( stated on September 16, 2021 in social media platforms: [Says President Joe Biden told people to get vaccinated against COVID-19 to protect themselves from hurricanes.]( By[Noah Y. Kim]( September 17, 2021 []( [Facebook posts]( stated on September 4, 2021 in Facebook posts: [“27 U.S. Air Force pilots resign over COVID-19 vaccination mandate.”]( By[Noah Y. Kim]( September 10, 2021 []( [Facebook posts]( stated on May 14, 2021 in Facebook posts: [An image shows the Blue Angels performing a maneuver called the “Hand of God.”]( By[Noah Y. Kim]( May 27, 2021 []( [Facebook posts]( stated on May 7, 2021 in Facebook posts: [“Montana is canceling unemployment because of a workforce shortage.”]( By[Noah Y. Kim]( May 12, 2021 []( [Facebook posts]( stated on April 28, 2021 in Facebook posts: [“Washington Post ends fact-checking for Biden for the remainder of his presidency.”]( By[Noah Y. Kim]( May 6, 2021 []( [Facebook posts]( stated on October 14, 2020 in Facebook posts: [A leaked email from a Liberal Party politician shows the Canadian government’s plan to “reset” the economy and seize private property.]( By[Noah Y. Kim]( April 29, 2021 []( [Instagram posts]( stated on March 25, 2021 in an Instagram post: [Says H.R. 1 gives immigrants illegally in the country “the right to vote.”]( By[Noah Y. Kim]( March 31, 2021 []( [Facebook posts]( stated on March 26, 2021 in Facebook posts: [Nostradamus predicted that a “feeble man” would rule the “Western World” after a time of “plague.”]( By[Noah Y. Kim]( March 30, 2021 []( [Facebook posts]( stated on October 17, 2021 in a Rumble video: [There is an “epidemic of plane crashes linked to vaccine-related strokes in pilots.”]( By[Noah Y. Kim]( October 19, 2021 []( [Instagram posts]( stated on August 14, 2021 in Instagram posts: [Department of Homeland Security “deemed as terrorism” behavior that includes “resisting COVID regulations” and “thinking the election was rigged.”…“In other words, if you are a Trump supporter, you are a terrorist.”]( By[Noah Y. Kim]( October 12, 2021 []( [Facebook posts]( stated on October 3, 2021 in Facebook posts: [“This ‘infrastructure bill’ on page 2,385 presents a federal property tax of 3 percent on all homes and land – both residential and commercial.”]( By[Noah Y. Kim]( October 4, 2021 []( [Bloggers]( stated on September 27, 2021 in Articles: [Norway decided “that (the coronavirus) should be treated like other respiratory diseases, such as the flu or cold, because… it is no more dangerous than those mentioned.”]( By[Noah Y. Kim]( September 30, 2021 []( [Facebook posts]( stated on September 26, 2021 in Facebook posts: [The Biden-backed infrastructure bill contains a provision establishing a per-mile driving tax.]( By[Noah Y. Kim]( September 29, 2021 []( [Facebook posts]( stated on September 1, 2021 in Facebook posts: [News cameras “shut off” just as Biden was asked if he gave the Taliban a “hit list” of evacuating American and Afghan officials.]( By[Noah Y. Kim]( September 28, 2021 []( [Facebook posts]( stated on September 26, 2021 in Facebook posts: [“The Arizona forensic audit found over 17,000 duplicates of votes.”]( By[Noah Y. Kim]( September 27, 2021 []( [TikTok posts]( stated on September 16, 2021 in social media platforms: [Says President Joe Biden told people to get vaccinated against COVID-19 to protect themselves from hurricanes.]( By[Noah Y. Kim]( September 17, 2021 []( [Facebook posts]( stated on September 4, 2021 in Facebook posts: [“27 U.S. Air Force pilots resign over COVID-19 vaccination mandate.”]( By[Noah Y. Kim]( September 10, 2021 []( [Facebook posts]( stated on May 14, 2021 in Facebook posts: [An image shows the Blue Angels performing a maneuver called the “Hand of God.”]( By[Noah Y. Kim]( May 27, 2021 []( [Facebook posts]( stated on May 7, 2021 in Facebook posts: [“Montana is canceling unemployment because of a workforce shortage.”]( By[Noah Y. Kim]( May 12, 2021 []( [Facebook posts]( stated on April 28, 2021 in Facebook posts: [“Washington Post ends fact-checking for Biden for the remainder of his presidency.”]( By[Noah Y. Kim]( May 6, 2021 []( [Facebook posts]( stated on October 14, 2020 in Facebook posts: [A leaked email from a Liberal Party politician shows the Canadian government’s plan to “reset” the economy and seize private property.]( By[Noah Y. Kim]( April 29, 2021 []( [Instagram posts]( stated on March 25, 2021 in an Instagram post: [Says H.R. 1 gives immigrants illegally in the country “the right to vote.”]( By[Noah Y. Kim]( March 31, 2021 []( [Facebook posts]( stated on March 26, 2021 in Facebook posts: [Nostradamus predicted that a “feeble man” would rule the “Western World” after a time of “plague.”]( By[Noah Y. Kim]( March 30, 2021 []( * 1 * 2 * 3 * 4 * 5 ## No, Biden didn’t wave to an empty field in Florida [Clear]( []( [Josh Stein]( stated on October 20, 2026 in an X post: [In North Carolina, “thousands more absentee ballots (are) being rejected this election — at a rejection rate twice as high as in 2022.”]( By[Paul Specht]( October 23, 2026 * * * []( [WinSenate]( stated on October 19, 2026 in an ad: [“After just five years in Washington,” Republican U.S. Rep. Ashley Hinson is “$8 million richer.”]( By[Caleb McCullough]( October 23, 2026 * * * []( [X posts]( stated on October 21, 2026 in X posts: [This video shows a former James Talarico student accusing him of misconduct.]( By[Jeff Cercone]( October 22, 2026 * * * []( [Club for Growth Action]( stated on September 14, 2026 in an ad: [U.S. Rep. Kathy Castor “repeatedly” violated “a law aimed at stopping members of Congress from insider trading.”]( By[Loreben Tuquero]( October 22, 2026 * * * []( [Kelly Ayotte]( stated on August 23, 2026 in an ad: [New Hampshire Democratic governor candidate Cinde Warmington “was a Purdue Pharma lobbyist. She said that OxyContin was a miracle drug.”]( By[Louis Jacobson]( October 22, 2026 * * * []( [JD Vance]( stated on October 17, 2026 in un foro con votantes de CBS News: [“La razón principal por la que los precios de la gasolina están tan altos es porque cuando Joe Biden era presidente, alrededor del 20% de la capacidad de refinación estadounidense dejó de operar”.]( By[Louis Jacobson]( October 21, 2026 * * * []( [Roger Marshall]( stated on October 16, 2026 in an interview with Sean Hannity: [Kansas U.S. Senate candidate Adam Hamilton “wants to shut down the beef industry.”]( By[Amy Sherman]( October 20, 2026 * * * []( [Ashley Moody]( stated on October 6, 2026 in a TV ad: [Florida U.S. Senate candidate Angie Nixon “backed a $4 trillion tax hike on everyone in this diner,” including a server and older adults.]( By[Maria Briceño]( October 20, 2026 * * * []( [Mike Rogers]( stated on October 18, 2026 in an interview: [Michigan U.S. Senate candidate Abdul El-Sayed “didn’t disavow” the Muslim Brotherhood.]( By[Caleb McCullough]( October 19, 2026 * * * []( [JD Vance]( stated on October 17, 2026 in a CBS News town hall: [“The biggest reason why gas prices are so high is because when Joe Biden was president, we had about 20% of American refining capacity that went offline.”]( By[Louis Jacobson]( October 19, 2026 * * * []( [Social Media]( stated on October 12, 2026 in an image: [If an election worker writes anything on your ballot before you put it in the voting machine, “your ballot could be disqualified.”]( By[Paul Specht]( October 16, 2026 * * * []( [Mike Collins]( stated on October 13, 2026 in in a debate: [U.S. Sen. Jon Ossoff is “all for abortion up until and past birth.”]( By[Maria Briceño]( October 16, 2026 * * * []( [Social Media]( stated on October 11, 2026 in publicaciones en redes sociales: [Una grabación de audio es prueba de que James Talarico fue dado de alta de un “hospital psiquiátrico” el 10 de octubre.]( By[Loreben Tuquero]( October 16, 2026 * * * []( [Senate Leadership Fund]( stated on October 1, 2026 in an ad: [New Hampshire U.S. Senate candidate Chris Pappas “lied about dating an Amazon lobbyist, then voted on bills Amazon lobbied on.”]( By[Louis Jacobson]( October 15, 2026 * * * []( [Senate Leadership Fund]( stated on September 28, 2026 in an ad: [“Sherrod Brown supports sex changes for minors. Irreversible surgery on kids. Like me,” Soren Aldaco.]( By[Loreben Tuquero]( October 14, 2026 * * * []( [Mariannette Miller-Meeks]( stated on October 2, 2026 in a Facebook post: [“I don’t own a single individual stock.”]( By[Evan Watson]( October 14, 2026 * * * []( [Donald Trump]( stated on October 2, 2026 in a rally in Alabama: [James Talarico is “a vegan” and “what they don’t show you is that, after every barbecue … he throws up.”]( By[Amy Sherman,]( McCullough]( October 13, 2026 * * * []( [X posts]( stated on October 11, 2026 in posts: [Audio recording is proof James Talarico was discharged from a “mental hospital” on Oct. 10.]( By[Loreben Tuquero]( October 12, 2026 * * * []( [Amy Acton]( stated on September 21, 2026 in a campaign ad: [Vivek Ramaswamy “pushed an Alzheimer’s drug that he knew didn’t work. He made hundreds of millions of dollars scamming people.”]( By[Cami Henry-Seymore]( October 12, 2026 * * * []( [James Talarico]( stated on October 6, 2026 in an ad: [Texas Republican Senate candidate Ken Paxton voted “to protect puppy abusers.”]( By[Caleb McCullough]( October 12, 2026 * * * [Load More]( #### Offices **District of Columbia** 1800 I Street NW Washington, DC 20006 **Florida** 801 3rd St. S St. Petersburg, FL 33701 727-821-9494 * [People]( * [Donald Trump]( * [JD Vance]( * [Mitch McConnell]( * [Mike Johnson]( * [Joe Biden]( * [State Editions]( * [California]( * [Florida]( * [Iowa]( * [Michigan]( * [New Hampshire]( * [New York]( * [North Carolina]( * [Pennsylvania]( * [Texas]( * [West Virginia]( * [Wisconsin]( * * [About Us]( * [Our Process]( * [Our Staff]( * [En Español]( * [Who pays for PolitiFact?]( * [Advertise with Us]( * [Corrections and Updates]( * [Newsletters]( * [RSS Feeds]( * [Recent Articles and Fact-checks]( * [Recent Fact-checks]( [Suggest a Fact-check]( **Follow us** []( **The Facts Newsletter** Sign Up * [Terms & Conditions]( * [Privacy Policy]( * [Copyright]( ©All Rights Reserved Poynter Institute 2020, a 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization []( * []( * []( * []( * [](mailto:?subject=Politifact%20-%20No,%20Biden%20didn%E2%80%99t%20wave%20to%20an%20empty%20field%20in%20Florida&body=Politifact%20-%20No,%20Biden%20didn%E2%80%99t%20wave%20to%20an%20empty%20field%20in%20Florida%20-%20 * [](