Mostly Verified
Confidence: Medium-High
StandardThe article’s core factual narrative about the May 2025 High Court judicial review outcome (parts of the Charity Commission’s 2022 Kids Company inquiry report found unlawful/irrational/unfair; key findings nonetheless upheld; report not quashed; and costs described as producing no overall winner) is strongly supported by primary-court material and official regulator updates. The principal limitations are (a) one important causal assertion framed as fact (“collapsed… after unfounded media reports of abuse”) which is harder to verify to the required standard because it compresses a complex chain of events into a single cause, and (b) some evaluative/characterising phrases (“dramatically exonerated”, “political and media vilification”) which are not strictly verifiable factual claims.
Verified Claims
Unverified Claims
Detected Biases:
Language Patterns
Emotional manipulation: 0.22
Limitations: ['Not all sub-claims in the long article were exhaustively checked (e.g., every quoted phrase and every descriptive adjective). Verification prioritised high-impact factual assertions about court findings, dates, and official actions.', 'The causal claim about ‘collapse after unfounded media reports’ would require deeper sourcing (e.g., contemporaneous investigations, official reports, and/or the 2021 judgment’s relevant passages) to confirm to a high standard.']
Level: Medium-High
Confidence is medium-high because the highest-priority claims (what the High Court decided; whether the report was quashed; whether financial mismanagement was upheld; whether predetermination allegations were rejected; and whether the Commission amended the report) are supported by primary and official sources. Confidence is reduced by one notable high-impact causal assertion about why Kids Company collapsed, which was not confirmable to the required standard within this targeted review and is therefore marked Unverified.
Query: High Court Mr Justice Sheldon Kids Company Charity Commission rewrite parts of 2022 inquiry report irrational unfair one-sided May 2025 judgment
Located primary judgment PDF and official GOV.UK inquiry page noting amendments and summarising key holdings.
Query: Charity Commission statutory inquiry report Kids Company 2022 mismanagement in the administration of the charity report pdf
Confirmed publication context and the Commission’s stated basis for the ‘mismanagement’ finding.
Query: Official Receiver v (Kids Company trustees) Mrs Justice Falk 2021 900-paragraph judgment neutral citation
Confirmed neutral citation [2021] EWHC 175 (Ch) and the widely reported ‘Most charities would… be delighted…’ quotation, but treated broader ‘exoneration’ characterisation as not fully verified here.
Query: Kids Company collapsed in August 2015 closure date
Confirmed closure date (5 August 2015) via UK Parliament committee page and sector press coverage.
Query: Camila Batmanghelidjh died 2024 date
Confirmed death reporting and date (1 January 2024; reported 2 January 2024).
# Watchdog’s Kids Company report was ‘one-sided’, but judge upholds key findings | Kids Company | The Guardian [Skip to main content]( to navigation](
Close dialogue 1/1 Next image Previous image Toggle caption
[Skip to navigation](
## Support the Guardian
Fund independent journalism with $5 per month
[Support us]( us](
[Print subscriptions](
[Newsletters](
[Sign in](
US
* [US edition]( * [UK edition]( * [Australia edition]( * [Europe edition]( * [International edition](
[The Guardian - Back to home The Guardian](
- [x]
* [News]( * [Opinion]( * [Sport]( * [Culture]( * [Lifestyle](
Show more Hide expanded menu
* - [x] News * [View all News]( * [US news]( * [US politics]( * [World news]( * [Climate crisis]( * [Middle East]( * [Ukraine]( * [US immigration]( * [Soccer]( * [Business]( * [Environment]( * [Tech]( * [Science]( * [Newsletters]( * [The Filter]( * [Wellness](
* - [x] Opinion * [View all Opinion]( * [The Guardian view]( * [Columnists]( * [Letters]( * [Opinion videos]( * [Cartoons](
* - [x] Sport * [View all Sport]( * [Soccer]( * [NFL]( * [Tennis]( * [MLB]( * [MLS]( * [NBA]( * [WNBA]( * [NHL]( * [F1]( * [Golf](
* - [x] Culture * [View all Culture]( * [Film]( * [Books]( * [Music]( * [Art & design]( * [TV & radio]( * [Stage]( * [Classical]( * [Games](
* - [x] Lifestyle * [View all Lifestyle]( * [The Filter]( * [Wellness]( * [Fashion]( * [Food]( * [Recipes]( * [Love & sex]( * [Home & garden]( * [Health & fitness]( * [Family]( * [Travel]( * [Money](
* Search input google-search Search
* [Support us]( * [Print subscriptions]( * [Newsletters]( * [Download the app](
* * [Search jobs]( * [Digital Archive]( * [Guardian Licensing]( * [Live events]( * [About Us]( * [The Guardian app]( * [Video]( * [Podcasts]( * [Pictures]( * [Inside the Guardian]( * [Guardian Weekly]( * [Crosswords]( * [Wordiply]( * [Corrections]( * [Tips](
* Search input google-search Search * [Search jobs]( * [Digital Archive]( * [Guardian Licensing]( * [Live events]( * [About Us](
* [UK]( * [UK politics]( * [Education]( * [Media]( * [Society]( * [Law]( * [Scotland]( * [Wales]( * [Northern Ireland](
- [x]
Camila Batmanghelidjh founded Kids Company in 1996. Photograph: Nick Cunard/Shutterstock
[View image in fullscreen](
Camila Batmanghelidjh founded Kids Company in 1996. Photograph: Nick Cunard/Shutterstock
[Kids Company](
This article is more than **11 months old**
# Watchdog’s Kids Company report was ‘one-sided’, but judge upholds key findings
This article is more than 11 months old
Court rules that Charity Commission must rewrite parts of its 2022 inquiry report into charity’s collapse
[Patrick Butler]( Social policy editor
Wed 21 May 2025 08.29 EDT First published on Tue 20 May 2025 12.43 EDT
Share
[Prefer the Guardian on Google](
A watchdog report into Kids Company, the children’s charity set up by the late [Camila Batmanghelidjh]( was “irrational”, “unfair” and “one-sided” in key criticisms it made of the way the charity was managed, a court has ruled.
Nevertheless, although the Charity Commission admitted it made errors and would have to rewrite parts of its inquiry report, [published in 2022]( the judge refused to quash it, and upheld other criticisms the watchdog made of Kids Company.
Although both sides said the ruling vindicated their positions, a separate ruling on costs by the judge, Mr Justice Sheldon, said: “In substantive terms, it seems to me that there was no overall winner or loser in this case.”
Alex Goodman KC, the lead counsel for the supporters of [Kids Company]( who brought the legal challenge, said:“We are hugely relieved and pleased with this judgment, which provides long-overdue vindication for Kids Company. This robust decision addresses fundamental wrongs and restores fairness and accuracy to the narrative.”
The Charity Commission said the ruling had largely vindicated its inquiry report, saying: “Today’s high court judgment has upheld our finding of mismanagement of the charity’s finances and has confirmed that it was based on ‘ample evidence’.”
Kids Company was one of the UK’s best-known charities when it [collapsed]( in 2015 after [unfounded media reports]( of abuse. It had been praised for its pioneering work in London, providing practical, emotional and educational support for thousands of severely traumatised children caught up in poverty and gang violence.
Batmanghelidjh, its [charismatic founder]( subsequently endured years of political and media vilification before being [dramatically exonerated]( in a high court ruling in 2021 that praised her achievements and paid tribute to the charity’s trustees.
The Charity Commission’s inquiry report into the collapse of Kids Company published a year later caused surprise when it delivered a formal finding of “mismanagement in the administration of the charity”, triggering the legal challenge by Batmanghelidjh that led to Tuesday’s ruling.
Lawyers for Kids Company, whose former clinical director Michael-Karim Kerman continued the challenge on behalf of Batmanghelidjh after [her death in 2024]( argued the commission’s report was vague and superficial, ignored positive findings of the previous year’s high court ruling, and “perpetuated stigma” around the charity.
Sheldon ruled the commission’s criticism of Kids Company’s management of payments to children in its care amounted to “innuendo” and was “extremely unfair”. He also concluded that a separate criticism of Kids Company’s trustees’ running of the charity was “irrational”.
Sheldon said: “Although the commission has a discretion as to what to include in the report of a statutory inquiry, that discretion must be exercised lawfully. Creating such extreme unfairness would not be lawful: in public law terms, it is irrational.”
But he upheld the commission’s conclusions on other aspects of the management of the charity, including its handling of client records, claims it made about the number of beneficiaries it supported, and its handling of a payroll issue. He rejected allegations the commission had predetermined the outcome of its inquiry.
[skip past newsletter promotion](
Sign up to First Edition
Free daily newsletter
Our morning email breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what’s happening and why it matters
Enter your email address
Marketing preferences
- [x]
Get updates about our journalism and ways to support and enjoy our work.
Sign up**Privacy Notice:**Newsletters may contain information about charities, online ads, and content funded by outside parties. If you do not have an account, we will create a guest account for you on [theguardian.com]( to send you this newsletter. You can complete full registration at any time. For more information about how we use your data see our [Privacy Policy]( We use Google reCaptcha to protect our website and the Google [Privacy Policy]( and [Terms of Service]( apply. after newsletter promotion
He said: “I do not consider that the report, looked at as a whole, was irrational. The fact that the report contains errors, and even a small number of irrational findings or observations, does not mean that the overall document is irrational.”
Kerman said he would continue to “carry on the fight for justice for all those who have been stigmatised by the untruthful narrative [about Kids Company] created by the media and the actions of various government bodies since the charity’s closure”.
He said: “Since Kids Company’s traumatic closure in August 2015 there has been a concerted attempt to denounce unfairly the charity and all who were touched by it, whether in the capacity of staff, volunteer, supporter or one of the thousands of vulnerable young children and families the charity served for nearly 20 years.”
This article’s headline was amended on 21 May 2025 to more fully reflect the text of the article.
Our annual appeal to defend press freedom
0 of 60,000 acts of support
## At this unsettling time
We hope you appreciated this article. Before you close this tab, we want to ask if you could support our annual press freedom appeal at this crucial time for journalism in the US.
In his first presidency, Donald Trump called journalists the enemy; in his second term, it's clear he's treating us like one.
From Hungary to Russia, authoritarian regimes have made silencing independent media one of their defining moves. Sometimes outright censorship isn’t even required to achieve this goal. In the United States, we have seen the administration apply various forms of pressure on news outlets since Trump returned to office. One of our great disappointments is how quickly some of the most storied US media organizations have folded when faced with the mere specter of hostility from the administration – long before their hand was forced.
While private news organizations can choose how to respond to this government’s threats, insults and lawsuits, public media has been powerless to stop the defunding of federally supported television and radio. This has been devastating for local and rural communities, who stand to lose not only their primary source of local news and cultural programming, but health and public safety information, including emergency alerts.
While we cannot make up for this loss, the Guardian is proud to make our fact-based work available for free to all, especially when the internet is increasingly flooded with slanted reporting, misinformation and algorithmic drivel.
**Being free from billionaire and corporate ownership means the Guardian will never compromise our independence – but it also means we rely on support from readers who understand how essential it is to have news sources that are immune to intimidation from the powerful.**
We know our requests for support are not as welcome as our reporting, but without them, it’s simple: our reporting wouldn’t exist. Of course, we understand that some readers are not in a position to support us, and if that is you, we value your readership no less.
**But if you are able, please support us today. All gifts are gratefully received, but a recurring contribution is most impactful, helping sustain our work throughout the year ahead (and among the great benefits, we’ll show you far fewer fundraising requests like this). It takes just 37 seconds to give. Thank you for protecting the free press.**
Support $5/monthly
Recommended
Support $15/monthly
Unlock **All-access digital** benefits: * Far fewer asks for support * Ad-free reading on all your devices * Unlimited access to the premium Guardian app * Regular dispatches from the newsroom to see the impact of your support * Unlimited access to Feast, the Guardian recipe app
Support once from just $1
[Continue](
Remind me in June
Explore more on these topics
* [Kids Company]( * [Camila Batmanghelidjh]( * [Charities]( * [Children]( * [Voluntary sector]( * [news](
Share
[Reuse this content]( "Reuse this content")
### Most viewed
* [ #### Polish ex-minister flees Hungary to the US after PM Magyar says country won’t protect people wanted elsewhere]( * [ #### Martin Short opens up about ‘nightmare’ death of his daughter Katherine]( * [ #### ‘Being offended isn’t the worst thing. Being poor is’: how Robby Hoffman became a controversial comedy sensation]( * [ #### A deadly bacterium is creeping up the US east coast. How worried should we be?]( * [ #### Greece scrambles to explain how explosive-packed drone landed in its waters](
* []( ### New regulator powers could stifle advocacy, UK’s largest civil society bodies warn 16 Apr 2026 * []( ### Fewer Britons giving to charity, study says, with donations down by £1.4bn 16 Mar 2026 * []( ### Oxfam trustee quits board over ‘cruel’ treatment of ex-boss 18 Jan 2026 * []( ### UK charities condemn ‘immoral’ plans to force asylum seekers to volunteer 14 Nov 2025 * []( ### National Trust to cut at least 550 jobs after £10m rise in costs from Reeves’s budget 11 Jul 2025 * []( ### Prince Harry accused of bullying ‘at scale’ by chair of charity he founded 29 Mar 2025 * []( ### Watchdog criticises ex-bosses of king’s charity over donor dealings 7 Jan 2025 * []( ### Counselling charity Relate set to be rescued from insolvency 27 Dec 2024 * []( ### Fixer for donations to king’s charities banned from trustee and director roles 5 Sept 2024
## More from News
## More from News
* []( ### US-Israel war on Iran Trump calls Iran’s response to peace plan ‘totally unacceptable’ as ceasefire frays 9h ago * []( ### Hantavirus Americans on hantavirus cruise ship to be repatriated as one tests positive 4h ago * []( ### US military Body of missing US soldier recovered off coast of Morocco 11h ago * []( ### Poland Ex-minister flees Hungary to US after PM Magyar says country won’t protect people wanted elsewhere 5h ago * []( ### Greece Greece scrambles to explain how explosive-packed drone landed in its waters 4h ago * []( ### Denver US transportation safety agency mulling investigation into fatal Frontier incident 14h ago * []( ### Martin Short Martin Short opens up about ‘nightmare’ death of his daughter Katherine 7h ago * []( ### Dua Lipa Dua Lipa sues Samsung for $15m over use of her image on TV boxes 5h ago * []( ### World Cup Fifa World Cup matches face heightened terror risk in US amid Iran conflict 20h ago
## Most viewed
## Most viewed
* [Most viewed Across the Guardian]( * [Most viewed in UK news](
### Most viewed Across the Guardian
1. #### [Polish ex-minister flees Hungary to the US after PM Magyar says country won’t protect people wanted elsewhere]( 2. #### [Martin Short opens up about ‘nightmare’ death of his daughter Katherine]( 3. #### [‘Being offended isn’t the worst thing. Being poor is’: how Robby Hoffman became a controversial comedy sensation]( 4. #### [A deadly bacterium is creeping up the US east coast. How worried should we be?]( 5. #### [Greece scrambles to explain how explosive-packed drone landed in its waters]( 6. #### [Female nudity and art that stinks: key takeaways from Venice Biennale 2026]( 7. #### [Saturday Night Live: Matt Damon is a stellar host of another standout episode]( 8. #### [Dua Lipa sues Samsung for $15m over use of her image on TV boxes]( 9. #### [Trump calls Iran’s response to peace plan ‘totally unacceptable’ as ceasefire frays]( 10. #### [Hantavirus: what happens to cruise ship passengers now and will they quarantine?](
### Most viewed in UK news
1. #### [UK firefighters called to one lithium-ion battery fire every five hours]( 2. #### [Mike Ashley admits he was behind video that brought down JD Sports chair]( 3. #### [Research sheds light on GI’s murder of seven-year-old girl in Northern Ireland in 1944]( 4. #### [Timely arrival: Great British Railways clock launches at London Bridge This article is more than **6 months old**]( 5. #### [Officer who cracked serial rapist Worboys case says justice system ‘close to exploding’]( 6. #### [Two men convicted over filming of antisemitic TikTok videos in London]( 7. #### [Euston HS2 back on track, say ministers as final tunnelling begins This article is more than **3 months old**]( 8. #### [Rapist John Worboys loses appeal against two life sentences This article is more than **5 years old**]( 9. #### [‘People can see it – but can’t use it’: mystery of completed East-West Rail line that has no passenger trains]( 10. #### [Two arrested over arson attack at former synagogue in east London](
* [UK]( * [UK politics]( * [Education]( * [Media]( * [Society]( * [Law]( * [Scotland]( * [Wales]( * [Northern Ireland](
* [News]( * [Opinion]( * [Sport]( * [Culture]( * [Lifestyle](
Original reporting and incisive analysis, direct from the Guardian every morning
[Sign up for our email](
* [About us]( * [Help]( * [Complaints & corrections]( * [Contact us]( * [Tip us off]( * [SecureDrop]( * [Privacy policy]( * [Cookie policy]( * [Tax strategy]( * [Terms & conditions](
* [All topics]( * [All writers]( * [Newsletters]( * [Digital newspaper archive]( * [Bluesky]( * [Facebook]( * [Instagram]( * [LinkedIn]( * [Threads]( * [TikTok]( * [YouTube](
* [Advertise with us]( * [Guardian Labs]( * [Search jobs]( * [Work with us]( * [Accessibility settings]( * California resident – Do Not Sell or Share
Support the Guardian
Available for everyone, funded by readers
[Support us](
[Back to top](
© 2026 Guardian News & Media Limited or its affiliated companies. All rights reserved.(dcr)