UK FACT CHECK POLITICS

UK FACT CHECK POLITICS

Independent reporting, transparently verified by objective AI fact-checking
Menu
Get Involved
Account
theguardian.com 08 May 2026 at 21:21

Over 330,000 excess deaths in Great Britain linked to austerity, finds study

View original article →
72
Trust Score

Mostly Verified

Confidence: Medium

Standard
Emotional Tone Low
How emotionally charged the language is (low is neutral)
Reading Level Academic
Suitable for age 23+ readers (grade 18)
Article Length Very long
2,394 words
Caps & Emphasis Moderate
2.5% of words are capitalised (high can indicate sensationalism)

Executive Summary

The excerpt is a Guardian news article (dated 4 October 2022) reporting on an academic paper in the Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health (JECH) estimating ~334,000 excess deaths in Great Britain (England & Wales plus Scotland) during 2012–2019 compared with expected deaths based on prior trends, and discussing potential links to UK austerity policies. Core quantitative claims about the excess-death estimate, period, geography, authorship/affiliations, and publication venue are supported by primary/near-primary evidence (the paper PDF via University of Glasgow repository and the Glasgow Centre for Population Health announcement) and by reputable institutional commentary (UK Parliament House of Lords Library). Some causal/attribution phrasing (“attributed to”, “likely to have been caused by”) remains inherently interpretive/model-dependent; these are best treated as partially supported rather than strictly proven causal facts.

Factual Verification

Verified Claims

  • The Guardian article is dated 4 October 2022 and reports on a study estimating over 330,000 excess deaths in Great Britain linked to austerity.
  • The study discussed was published in the Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health and is titled “Bearing the burden of austerity: how do changing mortality rates in the UK compare between men and women?”.
  • The study estimated approximately 335,000 more deaths occurred between 2012 and 2019 than expected based on previous trends (reported as 334,327 in the Guardian excerpt).
  • The analysis covers England and Wales and Scotland over the period 2012–2019 (pre-Covid).
  • The research was led/produced by authors affiliated with the University of Glasgow and the Glasgow Centre for Population Health (including Gerry McCartney and Ruth Dundas).
  • Gerry McCartney holds the title Professor of Wellbeing Economy at the University of Glasgow (from September 2021).
  • UK government communications in 2022 stated the Energy Price Guarantee would save the average household at least £1,000 per year for two years (based on then-current prices).
  • UK government communications in 2022 stated that almost all of the eight million most vulnerable households would receive at least £1,200 of cost of living support (in that year’s package).

Unverified Claims

  • More than 330,000 excess deaths in recent years can be attributed to spending cuts to public services and benefits introduced by a UK government pursuing austerity policies (strong causal attribution as a settled fact, rather than as a modelled association).
  • The additional deaths reflect increases in people dying prematurely after experiencing reduced income, ill-health, poor nutrition and housing, and social isolation (mechanistic explanation is plausible but not directly confirmed from the provided evidence in this verification pass).
  • Previously improving mortality trends started to change for the worse after austerity policies introduced in 2010 when tens of billions of pounds began to be cut from public spending (the broad trend shift is discussed in the literature, but the specific phrasing and ‘tens of billions’ quantification were not directly corroborated with a primary fiscal source in this targeted check).
  • The claim (as quoted) that “a great many more deaths are likely to have been caused by UK government economic policy than by the Covid-19 pandemic” (comparative statement depends on definitions, periods compared, and modelling choices; not fully verified here).
  • Specific subgroup numeric breakdowns in the excerpt (e.g., 237,855 male excess deaths in England and Wales; 12,735 among men in Scotland; 77,173 female deaths in England and Wales; 6,564 in Scotland) (likely derivable from the paper’s tables, but not fully cross-checked line-by-line in this run).
  • Percent changes for deprivation-stratified death rates described in the excerpt (e.g., 3% increase among women in the 20% most deprived areas of England after a 14% decline; 6%–7% increases in Scotland’s most deprived fifth) (likely in the paper, but not fully cross-checked against exact table/figure wording in this run).
  • That the Conservative government ‘signalled a fresh round of major public spending reductions’ immediately following the September 2022 mini-budget (contextual/political characterisation; would require additional contemporaneous budget/OBR/HMT sources to verify precisely).
  • That there were ‘proposals to impose a real-terms cut to benefits for millions of working-age people’ at that moment (requires specific policy documents/statements and dates to confirm).

Bias & Presentation

Detected Biases:

  • Causal overreach risk: news phrasing may compress a modelling-based association into definitive-sounding attribution (“can be attributed to”).
  • Selection/framing: emphasis on harms of austerity and calls for reversal may foreground one policy interpretation over alternatives (though it includes an on-record UK government response).
  • Advocacy adjacency: inclusion of stakeholder quotes (trade union; devolved minister) increases normative framing around ‘urgent need’ to change course.

Language Patterns

Emotional manipulation: 0.22

Confidence

Level: Medium

Confidence is medium because the highest-priority factual elements (paper existence, venue, timeframe, and headline excess-death estimate; plus the cited UK government support-figure claims) are corroborated with primary or near-primary sources. Confidence is reduced by (i) the inherently model-dependent nature of ‘excess deaths’ counterfactual estimates and the stronger causal attribution language used in the article, and (ii) incomplete line-by-line verification of all subgroup and deprivation-statistics figures contained in the excerpt during this run.

Article Content

# Over 330,000 excess deaths in Great Britain linked to austerity, finds study | Austerity | The Guardian [Skip to main content]( to navigation](

Close dialogue 1/1 Next image Previous image Toggle caption

[Skip to navigation](

## Support the Guardian

Fund independent journalism

[Support from $2.88 a week]( from $2.88 a week](

[Print subscriptions](

[Newsletters](

[Sign in](

US

* [US edition]( * [UK edition]( * [Australia edition]( * [Europe edition]( * [International edition](

[The Guardian - Back to home The Guardian](

- [x]

* [News]( * [Opinion]( * [Sport]( * [Culture]( * [Lifestyle](

Show more Hide expanded menu

* - [x] News * [View all News]( * [US news]( * [US politics]( * [World news]( * [Climate crisis]( * [Middle East]( * [Ukraine]( * [US immigration]( * [Soccer]( * [Business]( * [Environment]( * [Tech]( * [Science]( * [Newsletters]( * [The Filter]( * [Wellness](

* - [x] Opinion * [View all Opinion]( * [The Guardian view]( * [Columnists]( * [Letters]( * [Opinion videos]( * [Cartoons](

* - [x] Sport * [View all Sport]( * [Soccer]( * [NFL]( * [Tennis]( * [MLB]( * [MLS]( * [NBA]( * [WNBA]( * [NHL]( * [F1]( * [Golf](

* - [x] Culture * [View all Culture]( * [Film]( * [Books]( * [Music]( * [Art & design]( * [TV & radio]( * [Stage]( * [Classical]( * [Games](

* - [x] Lifestyle * [View all Lifestyle]( * [The Filter]( * [Wellness]( * [Fashion]( * [Food]( * [Recipes]( * [Love & sex]( * [Home & garden]( * [Health & fitness]( * [Family]( * [Travel]( * [Money](

* Search input google-search Search

* [Support us]( * [Print subscriptions]( * [Newsletters]( * [Download the app](

* * [Search jobs]( * [Digital Archive]( * [Guardian Licensing]( * [Live events]( * [About Us]( * [The Guardian app]( * [Video]( * [Podcasts]( * [Pictures]( * [Inside the Guardian]( * [Guardian Weekly]( * [Crosswords]( * [Wordiply]( * [Corrections]( * [Tips](

* Search input google-search Search * [Search jobs]( * [Digital Archive]( * [Guardian Licensing]( * [Live events]( * [About Us](

* [UK]( * [UK politics]( * [Education]( * [Media]( * [Society]( * [Law]( * [Scotland]( * [Wales]( * [Northern Ireland](

- [x]

Additional deaths over eight years prior to Covid pandemic may reflect people dying prematurely due to reduced income, ill-health, poor nutrition and housing, and social isolation. Photograph: Guerilla/Alamy

[View image in fullscreen](

Additional deaths over eight years prior to Covid pandemic may reflect people dying prematurely due to reduced income, ill-health, poor nutrition and housing, and social isolation. Photograph: Guerilla/Alamy

[Austerity](

This article is more than **3 years old**

# Over 330,000 excess deaths in Great Britain linked to austerity, finds study

This article is more than 3 years old

Research comes as government signals fresh round of public spending cuts

[Patrick Butler]( Social policy editor

Tue 4 Oct 2022 19.01 EDT Last modified on Tue 4 Oct 2022 19.08 EDT

Share

[Prefer the Guardian on Google](

More than 330,000 excess deaths in Great Britain in recent years can be attributed to spending cuts to public services and benefits introduced by a UK government pursuing austerity policies, according to an academic study.

The authors of the study suggest additional deaths between 2012 and 2019 – prior to the Covid pandemic – reflect an increase in people dying prematurely after experiencing reduced income, ill-health, poor nutrition and housing, and social isolation.

Previously improving [mortality trends started to change for the worse]( after austerity policies introduced in 2010 when tens of billions of pounds began to be cut from public spending by the Tory-led coalition government, the study said.

The study, published in the Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health, found there were 334,327 excess deaths beyond the expected number in England, Wales and [Scotland]( over the eight-year period.

The findings come as the current Conservative government signalled a fresh round of major public spending reductions after the financial crisis precipitated by its mini-budget, including [proposals to impose a real-terms cut to benefits]( for millions of working-age people.

The paper, led by the University of Glasgow and the Glasgow Centre for Population Health, concluded that there was a “clear and urgent need” for such policies to be reversed and new strategies to be implemented which protect the most vulnerable in society.

Prof Gerry McCartney, professor of wellbeing economy at the University of Glasgow and a co-author of the paper, said: “As the UK government debates current and future economic direction, it needs to understand, and learn from, the devastating effects that cuts to social security and vital services have had on the health of the population across the whole of the UK.”

[skip past newsletter promotion](

Sign up to First Edition

Free daily newsletter

Our morning email breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what’s happening and why it matters

Enter your email address

Marketing preferences

- [x]

Get updates about our journalism and ways to support and enjoy our work.

Sign up**Privacy Notice:**Newsletters may contain information about charities, online ads, and content funded by outside parties. If you do not have an account, we will create a guest account for you on [theguardian.com]( to send you this newsletter. You can complete full registration at any time. For more information about how we use your data see our [Privacy Policy]( We use Google reCaptcha to protect our website and the Google [Privacy Policy]( and [Terms of Service]( apply. after newsletter promotion

[ The lost decade: the hidden story of how austerity broke Britain Read more](

Co-author Ruth Dundas, professor of social epidemiology at the University of Glasgow, said: “This study shows that in the UK a great many more deaths are likely to have been caused by UK government economic policy than by the Covid-19 pandemic.”

The total excess deaths included 237,855 among males in [England]( and Wales, and 12,735 among men in Scotland. There were 77,173 excess female deaths in England and Wales, and 6,564 in Scotland.

Death rates among women living in the 20% most deprived areas of England increased by 3% after a 14% decline over the previous decade. In Scotland, premature deaths in the fifth most deprived areas increased by 6% to 7% among men and women, after previous decreases of 10% to 20%.

Previous studies have linked austerity spending policies in health and social care to [excess deaths in England]( as well as a [slowdown in life expectancy]( among the most deprived individuals.

A UK government spokesperson said: “Our growth plan will deliver economic growth across the UK – which is the best way to raise living standards for everyone. We’re also supporting households with rising prices through our energy price guarantee, saving the average household around £1,000 a year for the next two years, and providing at least £1,200 of additional cost of living support for 8 million of the UK’s most vulnerable households.”

The Scottish health secretary, Humza Yousaf, said: “This is a shocking finding which underlines the true human cost of austerity and reinforces the urgent need for the UK government to change course from its current budgetary proposals.”

The general secretary of the trade union Unison, Christina McAnea,said: “Austerity can never be a solution. It was a failed experiment that’s had terrible repercussions for communities across the UK and cost many lives.”

Our annual appeal to defend press freedom

0 of 60,000 acts of support

## At this dangerous time

We hope you appreciated this article. Before you close this tab, we want to ask if you could support our annual press freedom appeal at this dangerous time for journalism in the US.

According to a leading global watchdog, American democracy is now more imperiled than at any point since the 1960s, marked by a precipitous decline in press freedom – driven by mounting pressure from the Trump administration in the form of threats, criminal investigations, politicized regulation, frivolous lawsuits and, for public media, catastrophic funding cuts.

Meanwhile, organizations that are supposed to be independent like the FBI and the FCC, our radio and television regulator, have also been targeting press freedom under Trump-aligned leadership, with the FBI raiding a reporter’s home and the FCC threatening ABC’s TV licenses after Jimmy Kimmel made a joke about Melania Trump.

The response from some ultra-wealthy and corporate media owners, keen to appease the president, has been chilling: CBS News has been taken over by a Trump ally; CNN is poised to be taken over by the same billionaire; Jeff Bezos has continued to impose cuts and editorial interventions at the Washington Post; and multiple outlets have settled multimillion-dollar lawsuits from the administration to protect their business interests.

Democracy is best served by a robust, thriving free press. But when that freedom is under attack, it falls to a determined few news organizations to ensure the full truth still reaches the public. Owned neither by a billionaire nor a corporation, the Guardian remains dedicated to covering this administration with uncompromising moral and factual clarity – and to keeping trustworthy journalism paywall-free for the world.

Despite the risks of maintaining our fierce independence, what sustains us – and fills us with deep gratitude – is the unwavering support we’ve seen from readers. It is no exaggeration to say that we are here because of you: a majority of our funding comes directly from people like you responding to messages like this. Your support not only powers our work, but more importantly, it safeguards the financial independence that underpins our editorial freedom and courage.

**In honor of World Press Freedom Day this month, we’re looking for 60,000 readers to support our annual appeal with $5 or more. Do you have the means to be one of them? We’re especially grateful for anyone able to set up a monthly contribution: reliable funding is vital for sustaining us throughout this dangerous period, right to its end.**

**We would be hugely grateful for your backing to mark this global day of solidarity for independent journalism. Anything you can spare goes directly toward our work – not into the pockets of a billionaire or corporation with other interests at heart. It takes less than a minute. Thank you for protecting the truly free press.**

Support $5/monthly

Recommended

Support $15/monthly

Unlock **All-access digital** benefits: * Far fewer asks for support * Ad-free reading on all your devices * Unlimited access to the premium Guardian app * Regular dispatches from the newsroom to see the impact of your support * Unlimited access to Feast, the Guardian recipe app

Support once from just $1

[Continue](

Remind me in June

Explore more on these topics

* [Austerity]( * [Public sector cuts]( * [Conservatives]( * [England]( * [Scotland]( * [Wales]( * [Poverty]( * [news](

Share

[Reuse this content]( "Reuse this content")

### Most viewed

* [ #### What does a woman swimming in urine tell us about the state of the world? Lots! – Venice Biennale review]( * [ #### Trump announces Russia-Ukraine three-day ceasefire from 9 May]( * [ #### Greenlandic woman wins case against Danish authorities who removed her two-hour-old child]( * [ #### Frustrated by Iran, Trump at last seizes enriched uranium – but from Venezuela]( * [ #### ‘We love our Americans’: the German town rocked by Trump’s plan to withdraw US troops](

## Related stories

## Related stories

* []( ### Four in 10 UK parents struggle to afford essentials for newborns, study says 9 Apr 2026 * []( ### Children of austerity need a rescue plan, Gordon Brown says 14 May 2024 * []( ### ONS scraps plans to stop reporting the deaths of homeless people 26 Mar 2024 * []( ### Health inequalities ‘caused 1m early deaths in England in last decade’ 8 Jan 2024 * []( ### Austerity has led to NHS quality of care declining in key areas, study finds 5 Jul 2023 * []( ### Snow warning for south-east England as icy snap likely to trigger cold weather payments 9 Dec 2022 * []( ### Charities back UN envoy’s warning on further UK austerity 3 Nov 2022 * []( ### Austerity in England linked to more than 50,000 extra deaths in five years 14 Oct 2021

## More from News

## More from News

* []( ### Redistricting fight Virginia supreme court strikes down new congressional maps in win for Republicans 5h ago * []( ### US-Israel war on Iran US awaiting response from Iran over proposals for ceasefire deal, says Rubio 5h ago * []( ### Hantavirus Hantavirus misinformation runs rampant as the US is unequipped to respond to infectious disease health scare 4h ago * []( ### UFOs Pentagon releases first batch of previously secret files documenting reports of UFOs 2h ago * []( ### Ukraine Trump announces Russia-Ukraine three-day ceasefire from 9 May 2h ago * []( ### Venezuela Frustrated by Iran, Trump at last seizes enriched uranium – but from Venezuela 4h ago * []( ### UK elections Keir Starmer under pressure to agree exit plan after election mauling 3h ago * []( ### Canvas Cyber-attack on system widely used in US education disrupts final exams 4h ago * []( ### World Cup Fifa triples price of top World Cup final ticket to $32,970 as US politicians voice concerns 4h ago

## Most viewed

## Most viewed

* [Most viewed Across the Guardian]( * [Most viewed in Business](

### Most viewed Across the Guardian

1. #### [What does a woman swimming in urine tell us about the state of the world? Lots! – Venice Biennale review]( 2. #### [Trump announces Russia-Ukraine three-day ceasefire from 9 May]( 3. #### [‘We love our Americans’: the German town rocked by Trump’s plan to withdraw US troops]( 4. #### [Greenlandic woman wins case against Danish authorities who removed her two-hour-old child]( 5. #### [Frustrated by Iran, Trump at last seizes enriched uranium – but from Venezuela]( 6. #### [Rebel Wilson is a ‘fantastical liar’ who ‘made up terrible allegations against multiple people’, court told]( 7. #### [Trump’s looming defeat in Iran is a personal and political crisis]( 8. #### [Hantavirus misinformation runs rampant as the US is unequipped to respond to infectious disease health scare]( 9. #### [White House calls Mark Hamill ‘sick’ for posting AI image of Trump in a grave]( 10. #### [Meeting ‘Madyar’: the Ukrainian drones boss raining on Putin’s parade](

### Most viewed in Business

1. #### [Senate Democrats press top media regulator Brendan Carr to back off ABC]( 2. #### [US added 115,000 jobs in April in surprise gain amid Iran war uncertainty]( 3. #### [GameStop CEO opens eBay storefront to pay for potential eBay acquisition]( 4. #### [Reopening strait of Hormuz would have limited impact on cargo flows, says Maersk]( 5. #### [Powerful US utilities secretly fund ‘grassroots’ groups to sway cities away from switch to public power]( 6. #### [Great Western Railway to be nationalised in December]( 7. #### [Norwegian government attacked over decision to reopen North Sea gasfields]( 8. #### [US consumer confidence hits record low as Americans fret about rising prices; jobs report beats forecasts – as it happened]( 9. #### [Airlines still have to pay compensation if flights cancelled due to fuel crisis, EU says]( 10. #### [Totally grounded? How the jet fuel crisis could change our holidays – and world history](

* [UK]( * [UK politics]( * [Education]( * [Media]( * [Society]( * [Law]( * [Scotland]( * [Wales]( * [Northern Ireland](

* [News]( * [Opinion]( * [Sport]( * [Culture]( * [Lifestyle](

Original reporting and incisive analysis, direct from the Guardian every morning

[Sign up for our email](

* [About us]( * [Help]( * [Complaints & corrections]( * [Contact us]( * [Tip us off]( * [SecureDrop]( * [Privacy policy]( * [Cookie policy]( * [Tax strategy]( * [Terms & conditions](

* [All topics]( * [All writers]( * [Newsletters]( * [Digital newspaper archive]( * [Bluesky]( * [Facebook]( * [Instagram]( * [LinkedIn]( * [Threads]( * [TikTok]( * [YouTube](

* [Advertise with us]( * [Guardian Labs]( * [Search jobs]( * [Work with us]( * [Accessibility settings]( * California resident – Do Not Sell or Share

Support the Guardian

Available for everyone, funded by readers

[Support us](

[Back to top](

© 2026 Guardian News & Media Limited or its affiliated companies. All rights reserved.(dcr)

Share this fact check

← Check another article or image